Tonight we dipped into Pasta Mia in Adams Morgan–and if you know anything about this restaurant, it’s not a place people normally “dip” into. The line outside is usually historic and they don’t even open until 6:30 PM on weeknights, so waiting in a line outside the door is de rigueur. I’ve lived around the corner from Pasta Mia for nearly three years and we finally–impulsively–made our way there tonight.
The hostess (who, according to this Washingtonian review was very likely the chef’s wife, Antonietta) nodded us in the direction of a deluxe window seat where we could watch people on the street. The red checkered tablecloths sat upon tiny tables and the wooden chairs completed the rustic Italian scene. The menus arrived and simply stated: cash only, no substitutions, minimum $15.00 per person.
The menu is made for a pre-Adkins era, friends. Pasta, pasta, pasta says the menu. Fussili, gnocchi, fettuccine, capellini, ravioli–an authentic list of handmade pastas. The sauces come in three varieties: cream-based, red sauce with meat or without. There are enormous family style salads (we didn’t try one, but they looked fairly basic) and a bread basket, plus a single dessert (tiramisu) and a hearty wine list if you’re ready to pay $25-$50 for a bottle.
I asked our waiter to tell me about Pasta Mia–he had only been there four months and said there wasn’t much to say. Then I asked the busboy to share anything about the history of the restaurant–same answer. Rough start. Does this mean they will not have food recommendations?
The bread basket appears about 15 minutes into our meal and the busboy pours a little olive oil on to our plate. The sliced bread basket is a sad little thing when compared to amazing loaves I had tried in Florence. The stingy olive oil is disheartening, but I held steadfast–the reason we came here was for pasta.
Ten minutes later the waiter comes to take our order. Recommendations? Tortellini Rose (mix of red/cream sauce) and Spinach Ravioli with red sauce. Done, we’ll take them. Our half carafe of wine arrives and we were both pleasantly surprised by a nice simple red.
About 40 minutes into our visit, the pasta finally arrives. David’s pesto and spinach ravioli is a beautiful, steaming, bold serving (read: bold=enormous). My tortellini arrives in what looks very similar to Velveeta. Also steaming, also bold.
First bites. David’s eyes roll back. A groan from somewhere deep inside emerges. Tortellini is interesting, “Macaroni and cheese on steroids,” says David. The noodles in both cases are perfect. Perfect. Perfection. Word on the street is that the pasta is handmade by the chef–the solo cook in the restaurant.
We eat until we aren’t able to eat anymore, which isn’t very soon into the meal. Those are some big plates. The check comes, ouch. An unexpected nice meal on a weeknight.
We debate on our way out–why is it so good? Why do people, like ourselves, wait in line for their food? The restaurant has a measure of control, their expertise is what’s driving the meal, every dish on the menu is their recommendation. But the control is well, controlling. And it’s because what are our other options? Bucca Di Beppo. La Tomate. Dino. Ah yes, Dino. Next time.
Relevant Reads:
Little Serow review from Borderstan